THSACMG
THSUPBM
THSUPEC
THSUPFI
THSUPLM
THSUPMM
PRCLMG2
PRCLMGT
ECONRE2
By Colleen Flaherty
You have / 5 articles left. Sign up for a free account or log in.
It’s a common tradition within graduate programs: students bring food and drinks to meetings with their thesis committees, especially to their final defenses. And for many years, the psychology department at the University of California, Los Angeles, was no exception.
No more. The department’s faculty Executive Committee recently voted to end the unofficial practice, citing the added stress -- financial and otherwise -- it puts on students.
"We would like to move away from the expectation that oral exams be catered," reads a notice sent to UCLA's psychology professors and graduate students. "The Executive Committee has approved the addition of a simple rule to our Grad Handbook, stating that students are not allowed to provide food or drink for prelims/final oral exam."
Anna Lau, professor of psychology and vice chair of graduate studies, who wrote the notice, said Tuesday that there was "never an explicit statement that students must bring food." Rather, it was "a tradition that was transmitted and maintained through social norms."
In any case, she said, "my sense from students is that many are grateful that this is no longer an obligation."
Kate Wassum, an associate professor in the department, said that faculty members are “in positions of authority and need to be open to students’ concerns, and what we can do to correct them.” There’s always more to do, she said, but “this was one small, easy thing.”
Not every faculty member in the department expected students to bring refreshments to their meetings. Wassum didn't, for example. She first told students that they weren't expected to, and when that didn't work, she arranged to have food and drinks there herself. But there remained a general expectation in psychology that students would bring something like coffee and snacks, depending on the time of day, when they met with their faculty committees for their preliminary and final oral examinations. And while some students may not have minded, others found it distracting to think about buying, making and, perhaps especially, paying for food. Preliminary meetings typically include four or five committee faculty members, but final defenses can include audience members, as well.
Discussions about ending student-catered meetings accelerated following the publication of an opinion piece in Science last month called “Committee Members Shouldn’t Expect Ph.D. Students to Serve Coffee and Pastries.” Kate Bredbenner, a graduate fellow at Rockefeller University, wrote that she “never thought I would spend so much of my time and money setting up still-life-worthy displays of flaky croissants and shiny fruit for people who are judging my science, and that of my colleagues.”
Yet at her university and many others, she said, “students bring food to our thesis committee meetings and defenses, adding to the already sky-high pressure.” Bredbenner’s “first taste of it came five years ago, for my first committee meeting. I prepared furiously. I meticulously proofread my written proposal and aligned all the figures. My slides all used the same font. I had even prepared some extra slides to address possible questions my judges might ask.”
Even so, she said, “I was sure the meeting was doomed -- because I didn’t know how to make coffee.”
The solution to the problem, Bredbenner said, “is easy: Committees shouldn’t expect students to provide lavish spreads, or anything at all. We shouldn’t have to spend our money buying overpriced fruit salad or know how to make coffee to be considered successful graduate students. Our research should be enough.”
The piece sparked immediate conversations, not just at UCLA. A graduate student in Toronto who runs several social media accounts under the name Ph.D. Diaries, in part to critique the culture of graduate school, said on Twitter that she’d forgotten to bring coffee to her most recent committee meeting and was called out for it.
This move was inspired by conversations happening on Twitter. A few things: 1 - I don't even drink coffee 2 - I brought everything else to this meeting (the presentation, the report, the paperwork) 3 - I'm the only one at this table who makes less than a living wage. — PhD Diaries (@thoughtsofaphd) July 29, 2019
Some faculty members responded positively, at least online. One professor said she’d never thought about the “inequity” of the matter, and that she’d bring it up at her home institution. “You can’t underestimate how dense faculty are, even the well-meaning ones,” that professor wrote to Ph.D. Diaries.
Noel Brewer, professor of health behavior at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, responded that his department already “forbids doctoral students from bringing food and beverages to proposals and defenses. We train scientists, not caterers.” Brewer said he also pays for “trainees’ meals when we go out at conferences. And [he takes] them for a celebratory meal after the defense. Students should not pay.”
Brewer said this week that a colleague launched the policy seven years ago, as dissertation defense meetings "were becoming increasingly elaborate with tablecloths, refreshments and heavy hors d’oeuvres. We found it strange to have scientists turn into caterers."
The department also found it "inappropriate to set up expectations that put undue burden on people with limited means," Brewer said. "Many of us were just embarrassed to make such implied demands of students, given that many of us have a policy of always paying for trainees when we invite them to meals or drinks."
Ph.D. Diaries (who would like to remain anonymous) also said this week that she typically brings a carton of coffee to her meetings and intentionally didn’t bring it to the meeting she wrote about, to see what would happen.
“I think the general notion is absolutely ridiculous,” she said of student catering. “We are the only people at that table who do not make a living wage. I should not be expected to fund coffee.”
When her adviser told her she forgot the coffee, she said she responded like this: “But I didn't forget to bring everything else we need for this meeting -- the presentation, laptop, report, etc.”
At UCLA, a few professors questioned the change initially. Wassum said that in some instances, professors didn’t really know how students felt about bringing food. It is, of course, an awkward thing to bring up.
The department will now provide coffee and water at oral defenses, following a planned move.
However divisive the custom might be, it’s not meant to be punitive or stressful. Wassum said that the general mood at a thesis defense is celebratory. It’s a big moment in a student’s life. And to many, food and drink signal that. Defenses also tend to happen at a busy time of year, when people might need pick-me-ups.
“I myself find it totally unnecessary. If I need coffee, I can get coffee,” Wassum said. Still, “these things can be nice to have around, but students don’t need to be the ones to provide them.”
Lau wrote in her notice to students and faculty members that "one lovely aspect of this custom was that students often made agreements to support each other by providing refreshments for each other’s oral exams. We hope that students establish new 'buddy' traditions for supporting one another during these major hurdle steps (e.g., happy hour celebrations, being in the hallway for support during committee deliberations)."
The department also will restart the tradition of having a staff member take a photo of the candidate with their committee after the final orals, Lau said.
A new experiential learning initiative at Georgia State promotes research skills, critical thinkin
More from faculty issues.
Genia M. Bettencourt and Rachel E. Friedensen argue for systemic change in STEM doctoral programs.
Scott McLemee concludes his review of David L. Swartz's study of pro-Trump academics.
Rosemary Admiral writes that her sense of belonging at her institution has been shattered.
4 /5 Articles remaining this month.
A subreddit dedicated to PhDs.
For our defenses, we have to give a seminar open to the whole department. Usually about 20 or so people show up.
It is also custom for the defender to bring some type of food, snacks, or refreshments. Mine is in the afternoon after lunch.
Any budget friendly ideas I could bring for about 20 or so people?
By continuing, you agree to our User Agreement and acknowledge that you understand the Privacy Policy .
You’ve set up two-factor authentication for this account.
Create your username and password.
Reddit is anonymous, so your username is what you’ll go by here. Choose wisely—because once you get a name, you can’t change it.
Enter your email address or username and we’ll send you a link to reset your password
An email with a link to reset your password was sent to the email address associated with your account
Students prepared low budget snacks to their panelists earned various reactions.
Photo of Students who prepared low budget snacks to their panelists for their research paper oral defense went viral on social media.
Research paper or thesis has been one of the important requirements in school , especially in college ever since. This is one of the crucial for those who want to graduate from college, or even for professionals who want to finish post-graduate studies.
To be able to pass there are panelists who will check and review your project, and rate you according to your presentation. We could say that these guys can also be a threat to your project.
Recently, a netizen on Facebook named Rogelio Auguis shared a photo of their preparation to the panelists for the oral defense of their research paper presentation. What makes netizens amuse is when the snacks for their panelists was kind cheap and low budget.
The Facebook post found bottled water and cheap biscuits just because they prepared for panelists to judge and comment on their output. It has the caption “No, we are running out of research money.” The uploader wrote in his post.
Presumably, students did this to somehow eliminate the frustration and tension they felt during their oral defense presentation, which was not always easy to do. It also garnered various comments from netizens.
What can you say about this article? Just feel free to leave your reactions in the comment section.
For more news and updates, follow us on Twitter: @ philnews_ph Facebook: @PhilNews and; YouTube channel Philnews Ph
Crafting a thesis is significant, but defending it often feels like the ultimate test. While nerve-wracking, proper preparation can make it manageable. Prepare for your thesis defense with insights on the top questions you can expect, including strategies for answering convincingly.
Confidence enables you to present your research with conviction, while composure allows you to navigate any challenges with grace and clarity.
Remember, you know your thesis best, so trust in your expertise.
Stay composed and focused, relying on your thorough preparation. If you encounter a question you can’t answer, gracefully guide the conversation back to familiar topics.
By embracing these principles and staying confident and adaptable, you’ll navigate your thesis defense with ease.
Moreover, discuss the gaps you identified in the existing literature that motivated you to contribute to your field. What deficiencies or unanswered questions did you observe? How did these gaps inspire you to embark on your research journey with the aim of filling these voids? By articulating the specific shortcomings in the current body of knowledge, you demonstrate a nuanced understanding of your research area and underscore the significance of your work.
This question delves into the vital role your research plays within the existing body of knowledge, urging you to articulate its significance and impact. It’s not merely about the subject matter you’ve studied, but also about the unique contributions and advancements your research brings to your field. To effectively respond, delve into the intricacies of your work and its implications for the broader academic landscape.
Illuminate how your findings could influence future research trajectories. Explore potential avenues for further inquiry that emerge from your research findings. Consider how your work opens up new questions or areas of exploration for future researchers. By identifying these potential research directions, you demonstrate the forward-looking nature of your work and its potential to shape the future trajectory of your field.
Furthermore, relate these findings to the broader implications they hold for your field. Articulate how your research contributes to advancing knowledge or addressing pressing issues within your academic discipline. Consider the potential impact of your findings on theory, practice, or policy, highlighting their relevance and significance within the larger scholarly community.
Defending your research methodology entails a comprehensive understanding of its rationale, alignment with research objectives, and acknowledgment of potential limitations. It’s not merely about explaining the methods employed but also justifying why they were chosen over alternative approaches. To effectively respond, delve into the intricacies of your methodology and its implications for the study.
Be prepared to discuss the limitations inherent in your chosen methodology and how you mitigated them. Acknowledge any constraints or shortcomings associated with the selected approach, such as potential biases, sample size limitations, or data collection challenges. Demonstrate your awareness of these limitations and discuss the strategies implemented to address or minimize their impact on the validity and reliability of your findings.
Begin by outlining the techniques used for data analysis. Describe the specific methods, tools, and software employed to process and interpret the data collected. Whether it involved quantitative statistical analysis, qualitative coding techniques, or a combination of both, provide insights into the analytical framework guiding your study. Additionally, discuss the rationale behind the chosen analytical approach and how it aligns with the research objectives and questions.
In summary, when addressing inquiries about data analysis, consider the following key points:
Begin by naming the key theories and seminal works that guided your research. Identify the theoretical frameworks that provided the conceptual scaffolding for your study, as well as the seminal works that shaped your understanding of the research area. Discuss how these theories and references informed your research design, methodology, and analytical approach, providing a theoretical lens through which to interpret your findings.
Elucidate on how these frameworks shaped your hypothesis and analysis. Describe how the theoretical perspectives and insights gleaned from seminal works informed the development of your research questions, hypotheses, and analytical framework. Discuss the ways in which these theoretical frameworks guided your data collection and interpretation, influencing the selection of variables, measures, and analytical techniques employed in your study.
In summary, when addressing inquiries about theoretical frameworks, consider the following key points:
When addressing ethical considerations in your research, it’s essential to demonstrate a commitment to upholding ethical standards and protecting the rights and well-being of participants. Responding to inquiries about ethical protocols involves explaining the steps taken to ensure ethical conduct throughout the research process, describing the consent process and data protection measures implemented, and mentioning any institutional review board (IRB) approvals obtained.
Mention any institutional ethics review board approvals you obtained. Highlight any formal ethical review processes or approvals obtained from relevant regulatory bodies, such as IRBs or ethics committees. Discuss how the research protocol was reviewed for compliance with ethical guidelines and standards, including considerations of participant welfare, informed consent procedures, and data protection measures. By acknowledging the oversight and approval of institutional review bodies, you demonstrate your commitment to ethical integrity and accountability in conducting research involving human subjects.
Begin by detailing the novel insights your thesis provides. Articulate the key findings, discoveries, or perspectives that distinguish your research from existing literature and contribute to advancing knowledge within your field. Discuss how your study fills gaps in current understanding, challenges established assumptions, or offers innovative approaches to addressing pressing issues, highlighting its potential to generate new avenues of inquiry and broaden the scope of scholarly discourse.
In summary, when addressing inquiries about the contributions of your research to the field, consider the following key points:
Describe any blind or double-blind procedures employed in the study. Explain how blinding techniques were used to prevent bias in data collection, analysis, or interpretation. This may involve withholding certain information from researchers or participants to minimize the potential for conscious or unconscious bias to influence the results. Discuss how these procedures were implemented and their impact on enhancing the credibility and impartiality of the research outcomes.
When considering the potential trajectory of your research topic, it’s essential to identify areas where further investigation could yield valuable insights, discuss unexplored questions that emerged from your research, and reflect on the limitations of your study as starting points for future research endeavors. Responding to inquiries about the future direction of research involves suggesting fruitful areas for further investigation, highlighting unresolved questions, and leveraging the limitations of your study as opportunities for future exploration.
Reflect on the limitations of your study as starting points for future research. Acknowledge any constraints, biases, or methodological shortcomings that may have influenced the outcomes or interpretations of your study. Discuss how these limitations provide opportunities for future research to refine methodologies, address confounding variables, or explore alternative theoretical frameworks. Consider how addressing these limitations could enhance the validity, reliability, and generalizability of future research findings within your field.
Get new content delivered directly to your inbox, how to harness theoretical and conceptual frameworks for groundbreaking research, 25 short graduation quotes: inspiration in four words or less, related articles, first meeting with your dissertation supervisor: what to expect, left your dissertation too late ways to take action now, sample emails to your thesis supervisor, 3 inspiring master’s thesis acknowledgement examples.
When writing a research paper on food, there are many angles to explore to choose great research topics about food. You can write argumentative essay topics on food processing methods or search for social media research topics . Moreover, the food industry is advancing, and food styles are changing – another inspiration for an outstanding research topic about food. In other words, if you are looking for your ideal topic for food research , there are many places to look.
150+ ideas of experimental research titles about food, research title about food processing.
Research title about cookery strand brainly, trending experimental food research topics, research title about food safety, research title about food innovation for college students, thesis title about food safety for an a+ paper, attention-grabbing research title about baking, fascinating research topic about cookery, research topic about cookery strand for presentation, fun-to-write research topics related to food, example of thesis title about food and beverage, example of experimental research about food, contemporary food processing research topics.
Nevertheless, it can be hard to decipher what characterizes a good example of a thesis title for food. Hence, this article will briefly explain what factors to look for in a research title about food so-to-speak. Then, we will provide up to 150 food topics you can explore.
Personal interest is a vital factor to consider when sourcing the best thesis title about food . If you’re choosing a research title about cookery, you want to ensure it is something you’re interested in. If you’re unsure where your interest lies, you can check out social issues research topics .
Also, the availability of information on the topic of food is important in any research, whether it’s a thesis statement about social media or nutrition topics . Furthermore, choose several food topics to have options if one thesis about food doesn’t work out. Last but not least, ensure your chosen topic about food is neither too broad nor too narrow.
If you are unsure what title about food to work on for your research paper, here we are. Below are some of the best examples of thesis titles or professional thesis writers about food for students and researchers.
From food innovation research titles to food sustainability research topics , there are many areas of the food industry to explore. With the list of topics and tips for choosing a topic provided here, finding your ideal topic should be easier.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
June 17, 2010 9:46 AM Subscribe What food should I bring for my thesis defense? My thesis defense is tomorrow, and according to departmental tradition, I need to show up with something edible for my committee members. What should I bring?
In my experience, typically other grad students who are friends with the student defending rally together and provide baked goods and other snacks for the thesis defense.
Understand the Evaluation: Your defense isn't just about defending a thesis; it's also about showing you can contribute to the existing body of knowledge in your graduate program. Prepare for Varied Questions: Questions may cover everything from your thesis topic to your research methods, so be prepared for a wide range.
What preparations do you need to make your thesis defense a success? This article describes 10 tips that will give you the confidence that you need and prepare for the thesis defense adequately.
During our thesis defense, provided ng school lahat ng food. Students were provided breakfast and lunch and merong fruits basket na nasa buffet table kung saan kami naghihintay ng turn namin. Panelists, on the other hand, may nagseserve ng kailangan nila. All expenses were already included in school fees. Reply reply.
What is a thesis defense and how do you prepare for it the best way? This guide discusses what a thesis defense is and offers 6 tips for how to prepare.
TIPS NA PWEDENG IPAKAIN SA MGA PANELISTS DURING THESIS DEFENSE | PAPA SEP TV PAPA Sep TV 3.73K subscribers Subscribed 31 4.5K views 2 years ago #ThesisDefense #papaseptv
A thesis defense consists of a short presentation - about twenty or thirty minutes - on your thesis, followed by a discussion. That discussion is the actual defense of your thesis, as the thesis panel will be asking you questions and challenging you on your research, your conclusions, and your ideas.
Master your thesis defense with confidence! Discover 10 essential tips for graduate students to prepare and succeed in their final oral exam.
What is A Dissertation Defense? The first thing that you need to learn is what is a dissertation defense and what is its purpose. In simple terms, it is a presentation made by a student to defend all the ideas and views that are presented in a dissertation.
A step-by-step guide to preparing for your dissertation defense, written by a dissertation committee chair. Plus, what questions to expect.
I'm defending my Master's thesis on Thursday and have been encouraged by professors and Ph. D. students to bring something for my committee to snack on while I present. Unfortunately, I'll be presenting at 1 PM, immediately after everyone's lunch period. I'm thinking sweets would be a good idea, but my committee chair is a health nut and doesn't eat a lot of sugary stuff.
Keywords: qualitative research, food for defense panelist, research defense culinary, thesis defense food ideas, food for panelist ideas. This information is AI generated and may return results that are not relevant. It does not represent TikTok's views or advice. If you have concerns,please report at: ...
In Italy, it is normal to offer food after defending a thesis (not only phd, also bachelor and master), either directly on the place or by taking all the friends attending to a bar after the defense.
Due to COVID-19, defending your graduate thesis or dissertation in person is likely off the table. That doesn't mean you have to wait to defend. Many schools and programs are allowing remote defenses — meaning you could find yourself defending from your living room!
Prepare for your thesis defense with these tips and examples of common questions and how to answer them. ServiceScape offers expert guidance and support for your academic journey.
This amount may be spent for defense snacks on a per thesis group basis or as a lump sum for all thesis defense panelists. For the graduate final defense panels, the budget is P200 for every student enrolled in the thesis final defense and P280 for every student enrolled in the dissertation final defense.
It's a common tradition within graduate programs: students bring food and drinks to meetings with their thesis committees, especially to their final defenses. And for many years, the psychology department at the University of California, Los Angeles, was no exception.
The department provides food for the defense seminar like donuts and coffee. But it's expected that the PhD brings lunch/early dinner for the committee defense after the seminar! I usually do Panera sandwiches, or light pastry's but definitely coffee for the meeting! 1. Reply.
Learn how to make a thesis defense presentation that showcases your work at its best. Follow our expert tips and create a winning presentation.
Students Prepared Low Budget Snacks to Their Panelists Earned Various Reactions. Photo of Students who prepared low budget snacks to their panelists for their research paper oral defense went viral on social media. Research paper or thesis has been one of the important requirements in school, especially in college ever since.
The top 10 thesis defense questions (+ how to prepare strong answers) Crafting a thesis is significant, but defending it often feels like the ultimate test. While nerve-wracking, proper preparation can make it manageable. Prepare for your thesis defense with insights on the top questions you can expect, including strategies for answering ...
150+ Food Research Paper Topics Ideas for Students When writing a research paper on food, there are many angles to explore to choose great research topics about food. You can write argumentative essay topics on food processing methods or search for social media research topics.